پژوهش در آموزش معارف و تربیت اسلامی
Five pillars
Every check, with its source
Where a check was decided by reading the journal's homepage or its ISSN Portal record, we keep what we read: the page's SHA-256 fingerprint, the time, and the words that decided it.
Identity & governance
bfe552973f03069ab1a71323d4866c4336dd0258aa8d986b5b3bf778423b9cfa) — looked for the ISSN 2783-2252 — not foundf769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “title: Research in Islamic Education and Training”f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… Index Keyword Index Journal Info About Journal Aims and Scope Editorial Board Publication Ethics Indexing and Abstracting Peer Review Process Guide for Authors Submit Manuscript Reviewers Contact…”f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… under registration number 92268, dated 2022/12/11 Print ISSN: 2783-2252 Online ISSN: 2783-2147 Frequency: Quarterly Language: Persian, including English abstracts Open Access: Yes, free access…”f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… Website: https://tarbiatmaaref.cfu.ac.ir/?lang=en E-mail: Tarbiatmaaref@cfu.ac.ir Gmail: J.E.T.maaref2024@gmail.com Assignment of DOI code to articles: Yes. Articles have a doi code. Indexing &…”Editorial integrity
f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… Editorial Board Publication Ethics Indexing and Abstracting Peer Review Process Guide for Authors Submit Manuscript Reviewers Contact Us Login Login Register Persian”f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… Author Index Keyword Index Journal Info About Journal Aims and Scope Editorial Board Publication Ethics Indexing and Abstracting Peer Review Process Guide for Authors Submit Manuscript Reviewers…”f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — looked for "plagiarism", "similarity", "turnitin", "ithenticate" — not foundf769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — looked for impact-factor badges (SJIF, IIFS, Global Impact Factor, ISRA, Cosmos), "ISI indexed", speed promises ("publish within", "48 hours" …) or a self-declared impact factor — not foundTechnical standing
f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — looked for "doi.org/" — not foundf769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — looked for "/oai" (an OAI-PMH link) and "citation_" (Google Scholar tags) — not foundPreservation & access
f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… 4.0 International (<a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/">CC BY-NC</a> 4.0)</span></p> <p><span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times, serif;…”f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… refereeing time: 4-8 weeks Acceptance percentage: 25% Article Processing Charges: No Citation Style: The APA referencing style. Website: https://tarbiatmaaref.cfu.ac.ir/?lang=en E-mail:…”f769b789b294c83811d514d7731f848430556a518e5ec01bfbe13f3ad4d12ea4) — “… Quarterly Language: Persian, including English abstracts Open Access: Yes, free access to articles Article types: Research and review papers. Primary Review: 10 days, approximately. Peer…”Reach & citation
History
Every reading of this journal, newest first, with the methodology it was made under (the versions).
| Date | Grade | Score | Methodology |
|---|---|---|---|
| 03 Nov 2026 | D | 51 | 2026.10 |
What this means for you
Major gaps or warning signs. Before submitting, ask the editor about the failed items; if your institution has a journal policy, this journal probably does not meet it yet.
6 things the journal should fix. We can send them the list with your name as the requesting author:
Watch this rating
Hear by e-mail and on your dashboard when this journal's grade changes, when its records cannot be read, or when a hijack or clone signal appears. Watched ratings are re-checked at least every 7 days. Free for up to 10 journals.
Sign in to watch this ratingCertificate
A dated one-page certificate of this rating with all sources, for a thesis or promotion file.
Open printable certificate ↗Take it with you
The facts on this page as JSON — the grade, the score, when it was rated and under which methodology, every check with its source and what we read, and the history. Free, no key; any website may read it.
https://scholar.smartscholars.in/check.php?issn=2783-2252&format=json
Risk Radar
The other question — is this journal showing the behaviour that precedes delisting, hijacking or retractions? Fifteen written rules on the public record.
Score this journal →Show this rating on your site
Paste either piece into your own page — no key, no account, nothing to install. They show the public facts only: the grade, the date it was rated, and a link to every check behind it. When the rating changes, they change.
The badge — a small image that links to this page:
<a href="https://scholar.smartscholars.in/check.php?q=2783-2252" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><img src="https://scholar.smartscholars.in/badge.php?issn=2783-2252" alt="Journal Trust Rating of پژوهش در آموزش معارف و تربیت اسلامی" height="28"></a>
The card — a box with the grade, the score and the date, for a sidebar or a journal list (see it):
<iframe src="https://scholar.smartscholars.in/embed.php?issn=2783-2252" title="Journal Trust Rating of پژوهش در آموزش معارف و تربیت اسلامی" width="360" height="380" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
Before you submit
Journals now screen submissions for assistant-written text, paper-mill phrases, invented references and reused figures. See the same signals first, with the evidence — the manuscript is read once and discarded.
Manuscript Screen →Are you the editor?
Fix every item above with the Smart Scholars tools — Journal Audit, GetIndexed and DOI Doctor — and the rating updates on the next check: a rating older than 7 days is made again when it is opened, and you can re-check it at once from My journals.
Improve this journal →Three questions, if you run پژوهش در آموزش معارف و تربیت اسلامی
Answer what you like; we reply from a person, about this record. Nothing here is shown anywhere.
