Which journals are heading for trouble — before the list says so
Delisting, hijacking and retraction waves leave tracks in the public record months before anyone acts: a sudden flood of articles, citations that come mostly from the journal itself, authorship that moves to a new country overnight, a website that no longer matches the ISSN record. The Radar reads those tracks from OpenAlex, Crossref, DOAJ, the ISSN Portal and Retraction Watch, applies fifteen written rules, and gives you a dated score with every rule and every source on the page.
Rising this week
Nothing has moved up since the last weekly re-check.
Recently scored
| Journal | Risk | Band | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Biological and Agricultural Sciences Research Journal 2959-6521 | 0 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Multidisciplinary Journal of Emerging Needs of Curriculum 3078-3046 | 5 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Journal of Law and Social Sciences - University of Turbat 2959-877X | 5 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Interdisciplinary Journal of Medical Research 3106-9274 | 5 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| South Asia Journal for Minorities 3105-3750 | 5 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Jurnal Psikoedukasi dan Konseling 2580-4545 | 16 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Journal of The Physical Society of Indonesia/Physics Journal of the Indonesian Physical Society 1410-8860 | 0 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Aksis Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra Indonesia 2580-9040 | 21 | Guarded | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences 1978-3051 | 16 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| International Journal of Health Economics and Social Sciences (IJHESS) 2685-6689 | 19 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Andalas Dental Journal 2338-4891 | 8 | Low | 04 Nov 2026 |
| Jurnal Abdimas Indonesia 2797-2887 | 25 | Guarded | 04 Nov 2026 |
How the score is made
Fifteen signals, each a written rule with a threshold, each read from one public source. Points add up to a score out of 100: Low 0–19 · Guarded 20–39 · Elevated 40–64 · High 65+. Fewer than five measurable signals → "not enough data", never a low score the journal did not earn. Re-scored weekly for watched journals; a score moves only when the record moves.
Output has stopped up to 10
Citations mostly from itself up to 15
Citations concentrated in one other journal up to 10
Authorship shifted to a new country up to 10
Retracted articles up to 15
AI-writing signals in recent abstracts up to 12
Tortured phrases in recent abstracts up to 10
Scope spread thin across fields up to 8
Open-access journal not in DOAJ up to 5
No digital preservation on record up to 8
Articles deposited without reference lists or abstracts up to 8
Title or website differ from the ISSN record up to 12
Title shared with another journal up to 6
On a hijacked- or removed-journal list up to 40
What it is not
Not a blacklist, not a verdict on any article, not an impact factor. A high score says the public record shows patterns that have preceded trouble elsewhere; a committee reads the signals, then decides. The Journal Trust Rating (Journal Check) answers the other question — is the journal maintained to indexer standard today.
For institutions
Watch every journal your faculty publish in, get one mail the week a band rises, pull scores into your own systems by API, and judge publications against your own policy — the Research Integrity Desk does that.
GET https://scholar.smartscholars.in/radar.php?issn=2456-5660&format=json
