Skip to content
Smart Scholars🛡 Scholar Shield🏛 Research Integrity Desk🧩 Portfolio Console📰 Journals🔧 DOI MembersTools🔎 Journal AuditGI GetIndexedDr DOI Doctor
Journal Risk Radar · free · public data only

Which journals are heading for trouble — before the list says so

Delisting, hijacking and retraction waves leave tracks in the public record months before anyone acts: a sudden flood of articles, citations that come mostly from the journal itself, authorship that moves to a new country overnight, a website that no longer matches the ISSN record. The Radar reads those tracks from OpenAlex, Crossref, DOAJ, the ISSN Portal and Retraction Watch, applies fifteen written rules, and gives you a dated score with every rule and every source on the page.

You have started 5 fresh scores this hour — the limit for visitors. Scores already computed stay free; try a new one in an hour, or sign in to an institution plan for unlimited scoring.
Journals scored
4,082
Low
3512
Guarded · Elevated
276
High
0

Rising this week

JournalRiskMovedWhy
Thermal Science
0354-9836 · Vinča Institute of Nuclear Sciences
13+13Retracted articles; Open-access journal not in DOAJ
International Education and Research Journal
2454-9916 · Koryfi Group of Media & Publications
25+12Publication volume surge; Open-access journal not in DOAJ
جامعه‌شناسی سیاسی جهان اسلام
2980-9371 · Shahed University
18+10Output has stopped; No digital preservation on record
رهیافت انقلاب اسلامی
2980-9118 · Abdolmotaleb Abdollah
10+10Output has stopped
نشریه علمی-پژوهشی مهندسی معدن
1735-7616 · Iranian Society of Mining Engineering
10+10Output has stopped
Ife Journal of Agriculture
0331-6351 · Obafemi Awolowo University
5+5Open-access journal not in DOAJ
Journal for Business, Development and Leadership
2957-7136
?+5Open-access journal not in DOAJ
International Journal of Social Sciences and Scientific Studies
2787-0146
5+5Open-access journal not in DOAJ
JELM
2709-1236 · Allama Iqbal Open University
5+5Open-access journal not in DOAJ
INTERANTIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH IN ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT
2582-3930 · Edtech Publishers (OPC) Private Limited
16+3Publication volume surge; Articles deposited without reference lists or abstracts
Gaceta Médica de México
0016-3813 · Academia Nacional de Medicina de México
11+3Articles deposited without reference lists or abstracts; Retracted articles
Filomat
0354-5180 · University of Niš
8+3Open-access journal not in DOAJ; Retracted articles

Recently scored

JournalRiskBandChecked
Insects
2075-4450
3Low20 Nov 2026
Baltic Journal of Modern Computing
2255-8942
19Low20 Nov 2026
Maestro y sociedad
1815-4867
8Low20 Nov 2026
Jurnal Manajemen dan Bisnis
2337-5523
11Low20 Nov 2026
International Journal of Learning & Teaching
1986-454X
0Low20 Nov 2026
Revue Malienne d Infectiologie et de Microbiologie
1987-0876
13Low20 Nov 2026
annales de biologie animale biochimie biophysique
0003-388X
21Guarded20 Nov 2026
Terra
0040-3741
13Low20 Nov 2026
Baltic Surveying
2255-999X
5Low20 Nov 2026
مجلة الدراسات التاريخية و الاجتماعية
2412-3501
8Low20 Nov 2026
Environment Technology Resources Proceedings of the International Scientific and Practical Conference
1691-5402
8Low20 Nov 2026
Notes and Queries
0029-3970
8Low20 Nov 2026

How the score is made

Fifteen signals, each a written rule with a threshold, each read from one public source. Points add up to a score out of 100: Low 0–19 · Guarded 20–39 · Elevated 40–64 · High 65+. Fewer than five measurable signals → "not enough data", never a low score the journal did not earn. Re-scored weekly for watched journals; a score moves only when the record moves.

Publication volume surge up to 15
Output has stopped up to 10
Citations mostly from itself up to 15
Citations concentrated in one other journal up to 10
Authorship shifted to a new country up to 10
Retracted articles up to 15
AI-writing signals in recent abstracts up to 12
Tortured phrases in recent abstracts up to 10
Scope spread thin across fields up to 8
Open-access journal not in DOAJ up to 5
No digital preservation on record up to 8
Articles deposited without reference lists or abstracts up to 8
Title or website differ from the ISSN record up to 12
Title shared with another journal up to 6
On a hijacked- or removed-journal list up to 40

The full rule table and what the score is not →

What it is not

Not a blacklist, not a verdict on any article, not an impact factor. A high score says the public record shows patterns that have preceded trouble elsewhere; a committee reads the signals, then decides. The Journal Trust Rating (Journal Check) answers the other question — is the journal maintained to indexer standard today.

For institutions

Watch every journal your faculty publish in, get one mail the week a band rises, pull scores into your own systems by API, and judge publications against your own policy — the Research Integrity Desk does that.

GET https://scholar.smartscholars.in/radar.php?issn=2456-5660&format=json

Share this page

Share this page

Ask AI about this page

Everything Smart Scholars runs

Nine sites, one account. A journal starts at the audit; an author starts at Scholar Shield.

What we do: DOIs registered from what a journal already has · Crossref records completed — references, abstracts, licences, ORCID iDs, affiliations and ROR IDs, funding · DOIs that resolve · articles preserved · journals rated on the public record · see everything we do →

Book a free call

For journals & publishers

Start with the audit — ₹4,999 per journal, and the gate to everything else.

DOI care

Every service on one journal profile — each previews first and acts only on your approval.

  • DOI Doctor — check & repairevery DOI tested at doi.org and Crossref; dead links, abstracts, licences, ORCIDs
  • Smart Deposita new DOI from your PDF, Word file, article page, JATS XML or spreadsheet — every value shown with its source, deposited once you confirm it
  • DOI census (Excel)site against Crossref, both directions, with a copy-paste fix per article
  • Backfile DOIsDOIs for older articles that never had one — no per-DOI fee of ours
  • DOIs for conference proceedingsthe conference, the volume and every paper — registered in the organiser's own name
  • Write DOIs into OJSthe verified DOIs pushed onto your article pages through your own API
  • Silent-failure monitorweekly checks of site, OAI-PMH, Scholar tags, ISSN, preservation, hijack lists
  • Journal Radarevery journal, every day: SSL, DNS, redirects, robots.txt, OJS, DOIs, Crossref metadata, broken links — what broke since yesterday first
  • Verified metrics & badgesa public, dated, source-linked metrics page and a "cited by" badge
  • Quality dossier (PDF)one PDF for universities, authors and reviewers
  • Author citation enginethe citation steps emailed to each author from the journal's own mailbox
  • JATS XMLmachine-readable JATS per article
  • Duplicate articlesthe same paper published twice — you choose which copy stays

For authors & researchers

Free to use. Nothing you check is shared with the journal.

For institutions, sponsors & DOI operators

Smart Scholars

Mon–Sat, 10:00–19:00 IST. The Ask AI button on every page answers about our services at any hour.

News

Policies

Indexing consultancy

Every index by its own rules — the guides, and the work done for you.

What we can register a DOI for

20 kinds of record, one account, one place. Every one gets a DOI that resolves, metadata that indexes read, and a record that stays correct afterwards.

Journals

  • Journal articles
  • Journal titles
  • Pending publications
  • Peer reviews
  • Preprints & posted content

Books & conferences

  • Books
  • Book chapters
  • Book series
  • Book sets
  • Conference proceedings
  • Proceedings series
  • Conference papers

Other research output

  • Theses & dissertations
  • Reports & working papers
  • Report series
  • Standards
  • Databases
  • Datasets
  • Figures, tables & supplements

Funding

  • Grants & funding awards

Elsewhere

The same company, in the places our publishers already read.
Add Smart Scholars as a preferred source on GoogleSee more of our newsroom in Google’s Top Stories.
Smart Scholars · Every service on one pageNewsroom posts CC BY 4.0 · DOI metadata CC0 · everything else ©Data from OpenAlex (openalex.org), CC0 · Crossref · ISSN Portal · DOAJContactCookie settings
WhatsApp