| Pillar | Points | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Identity & governance | 2 / 25 (12 unchecked) | 25 |
| Editorial integrity | 9 / 25 (25 unchecked) | 25 |
| Technical standing | 10 / 20 (9 unchecked) | 20 |
| Preservation & access | 0 / 15 (13 unchecked) | 15 |
| Reach & citation | 7 / 15 (2 unchecked) | 15 |
| Check | Result | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| ISSN registered (ISSN Portal) | BAD 0/8 | no record for this ISSN | portal.issn.org |
| ISSN key-title matches | NA 0/3 | not checked | portal.issn.org |
| Journal website live and on HTTPS | BAD 0/3 | HTTP 403 | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| Editorial board named | NA 0/4 | site not readable | |
| ISSN displayed on the site | NA 0/3 | site not readable | |
| Contact published | NA 0/2 | site not readable | |
| Publisher identified | OK 2/2 | Wiley (Blackwell Publishing) | api.crossref.org |
| Peer-review policy published | NA 0/7 | not checked | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| Publication ethics / malpractice policy | NA 0/6 | not checked | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| Plagiarism screening stated | NA 0/3 | not checked | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| No predatory-style red flags | NA 9/9 | not checked | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| Crossref member — DOIs registered | OK 5/5 | 1370 DOIs on record | api.crossref.org |
| Crossref metadata completeness (current articles) | OK 5/6 | abstracts 72% · licences 89% · ORCIDs 65% · references 64% | api.crossref.org |
| DOIs displayed as links on the site | NA 0/2 | site not readable | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| OAI-PMH endpoint and Google Scholar tags | NA 0/3 | not checked | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| Registered DOIs resolve to a live page | NA 0/2 | not checked — no DOI check has been run for this journal | |
| Articles on the site carry a registered DOI | NA 0/2 | not checked — no DOI census has been run for this journal | |
| Preservation (Keepers Registry / archives) | NA 0/6 | not checked | portal.issn.org |
| Creative Commons licence stated | NA 0/4 | not checked | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| APC / fee transparency | NA 0/3 | not checked | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| Open-access statement | WARN 0/2 | no OA statement | esj-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com |
| Listed in DOAJ | WARN 0/6 | not in DOAJ | doaj.org |
| Indexed and cited in OpenAlex | OK 5/5 | 1363 works · 19117 citations · h-index 50 | openalex.org |
| Citation depth (h-index ≥ 5) | OK 2/2 | h-index 50 | openalex.org |
| Other verified index / registry listings | NA 0/2 | none recorded |
The Journal Trust Rating is computed by Smart Scholars from public registries (ISSN Portal, Crossref, DOAJ, OpenAlex, Keepers Registry) and the journal's own website at the time shown. It is not an impact factor and does not assess the quality of individual articles. Methodology: https://institutions.smartscholars.in/methodology.php. Verify this certificate: https://scholar.smartscholars.in/check.php?q=0913-557X